Adapting to changes in commitment... a one way street in recruitment?
Recently, I had an unpleasant experience with a recruiting company. Recruiters in clinical reasearch are often reached out to, when there is a need in personnel that requires an immediate solution in form of hiring a freelance worker in order to fill that identified gap. In many cases, this means short time to onboard and get started in a project as quickly as possible. In this specific case, I was handed a project, where around 10(!) visits would have been required in June onsite and a few more remote, when I started in May. May was supposed to be my onboarding time, where I agreed to work 30%, because I was limited by another project I am already on. By June, I was supposed to work 80% of my time for the new position. While 10 visits can never be covered with 80% working time, everyone in clinical research should be aware of this fact.
However, onboarding was not going ideally, from a technical point of view and from the practical kind of view. I won´t go into details, but the situation was not very satisfying. During a Study Meeting from the other client, who I was and am still working for, I learned that timelines for that project had shifted and the expectation was now, that the study will be completed by August, what meant, that the visits I would still need to do, would have to be done in a much shorter period than previously anticipated. The project was initially planned to last until November. So much more work would have to fit into much less time than expected.
In addition, I have a health issue, that requires some attention and potentially a surgery in the near future, which I learned about around the same time. So I called my contact person at the newly acquired client and explained my situation with the other client (I did not say anything about the health issue, as it is not yet clear how this will be handled) and we mutually decided to part ways, as they would need support mostly in June and July. We parted on good terms. I was not knowing at the time of signing up with them, that these changes were coming, and they require someone who can focus on their needs.
After speaking with the client, I called the recruiter, who had organized this match and explained the situation to them as well. I was upfront and honest and got a dry reply which sticks with me still.
Recruiter:“And you definetely could not see this coming?“
Me: „No, I am sorry, I didn´t“
Recruiter: „So, you are preferring the other client over us?“
Me: „It´s not about preference, but I am working with this client for over a year, and I won´t let them down on the last stretch of the study“
Recruiter: „But you gave us a commitment as well“
Me: „I know, but circumstances were different then“
We ended the call. I don´t think this recruiter will ever come back to me again. It left me with the feeling they took my decision personally, while it was the best thing to do I could think of, knowing I would not be able to accomodate the needs of both clients. While I know, that the recruiter will also not get the assignment fee they would have gotten if I had gone on with the client, plus the time and effort they invested into presenting me and setting me up, I think it would have been unfair and unsatisfying, as I had already known I would not have been able to cater to both clients, if I had continued.
So, what I am asking myself is, is it better to be honest, tell your limitations and let everyone involved know what is going on or should you bite your teeth, pull through despite knowing, `this will be impossible` and potentially disappoint everyone, including yourself? And: especially recruiters know how quickly things can change and how quickly needs in a project may change, and yet, you get the answer „but you gave us a commitment, too“, when you are being transparent. Of course, I did, and I am very sorry I can´t keep it, but I rather be honest upfront instead of letting the client feel that I cannot deliver what they need and expect from their new hire.
What do you think about this? Especially from a recruiting point of view? Have you experienced things like this? How did you handle this kind of situation?




